I don’t think there is anyone in the US that isn’t aware of Mitt Romney’s writing off of 47% of the American electorate, I don’t wish to dwell on this act of gross stupidity, enough has been said and it is my belief that Romney is now an absolutely flawed presidential candidate and quite possibly unelectable. In describing nearly half of the people of the US as ‘moochers’, Romney has inadvertently attacked over 40% of the Republican base that were expected to vote for him in the November election. Of the 47% around 130 million people that don’t pay income tax, 60 million are seniors and further 57 million don’t earn enough to pay federal income, they do however pay payroll taxes, property taxes and sales taxes, the rest are people that are unemployed, the disabled and those who have fallen out of the system. The problem with Romney’s remarks is that at least 40% of the people he referred to are Republican voters and many of them are exactly the people that attend Tea Party protests and feel that their ‘country is under threat’.

Republican ‘Red State’ USA, is engaged in the kind of cognitive dissonance that makes Europeans like myself exclaim ‘Only in America’. Right to work legislation and the lack of a social safety net, in Red State America this has lead to the incomes of unskilled and semi-skilled workers declining by around 40% in inflation adjusted terms since 1980, people that were the American middle class are now the working poor, they are struggling, they are disaffected and they have been manipulated into the kind of thinking that destroys hope and belief in the American dream ideal that anyone in America through hard work and perseverance can progress financially and socially.

Educationally America is falling behind, the greatest demographic shift is in the attainment of the children of white, blue collar workers that live in Red states, the high school drop out rate is higher amongst this group than any other group, higher than African Americans, higher than latinos and nearly 37% higher than than that of those from similar socio-economic backgrounds in Europe. Thirty years ago there were jobs and opportunities for those with little formal education, America needed unskilled and semi-skilled workers, however today those jobs and that kind of production has been off-shored to China and to developing nations, American production cannot compete on that kind of cost basis. America needs skilled, educated workers that can embrace the challenges of global production, young people that are mathematically and scientifically literate to work in industries that are high wage and high skill. This is the future and this is the vision of America that we on the centre left have to sell to the American population has an whole.

Unlike Mitt Romney we cannot turn our backs on the poor and disaffected, even those that are adhering to the Tea Party ideology, they are our people too. Since the end of the Civil War, the American political right and vested interest groups have managed to stall social and economic progress by using divide and rule tactic of the fear of the other. African Americans, the Irish, Mexicans and other immigrants are presented as coming to take ‘Our Jobs’. Latterly we have this notion that Christianity is under threat from gay marriage and women’s rights and this completely false idea that minority groups are living in the lap of luxury at the expense of the American tax payer. It is our duty to address this ignorance and confront the vested interest groups, demonstrating exactly what the Koch brothers and their ilk have to gain from the Tea Party agenda and show these folks that are being manipulated by people that have no interest in their well being. Yes, this is possible.

The God, Guns and Old Glory agenda is predicated in fear and of the loss of economic status, it becomes much easier to blame ‘The Other’ an African American president than look for the real problems and find answers that benefit the whole of society. A second Obama term offers a real opportunity to address this once and for all in American society and a chance for the social democratic centre left to make real progress, if those who are currently supporting the Tea Party agenda can be made to feel that their children and grand children can be given greater social and economic opportunities and prosperity then maybe some of the more prejudicial beliefs can be tackled. But the single most important thing that we on the centre left must never forget is that all people are our people, they may support ideas that we find repellent, they maybe plagued by racist, sexiest and homophobic prejudices but they will always remain human beings and deserving of humanity. Unlike Mitt Romney we must not exclude and reject a significant proportion of American citizens.


2 thoughts on “47%?

  1. unfortunately the divide between americans existed long before america existed. north/south divisions, aristocratic property owners (of which a significant portions of our founders were a part of) versus unskilled laborers and non-property owners, the gender gap, and, of course, slaves and the master class… the divisions between americans have never really gone away — we’ve become better at spinning the myth of a united people. that myth requires a certain amount of collective amnesia — to forget the past as quickly as possible and to screen out any conflicting account of the present reality that does not conform to the american mythology (we are a christian nation founded on the principles of equality and equal opportunity for all).
    the paradox of the american myth, of course, is the question of how does one preserve the idea of freedom while simultaneously denying it (in actuality) to a large portion of the people? keeping the population uneducated is one way, but a more effective way is to keep what they need away from them, while admonishing them for lacking the skills/education, etc. that is necessary to perform in the modern workforce. steve jobs told president obama that american jobs that have left to china and elsewhere are not returning not just because american workers lack the proper skills (which is something that can fixed), but because chinese workers are willing to give up their freedom to work. chinese workers are willing to live in barracks and be ready to work ANYTIME their employer demands that they do so. it seems that the biggest problem for business (and politics) is that americans enjoy the idea of freedom so much that they actually believe they deserve to be free.

    i know that my response has nothing to do with your post. i apologize.

    btw: kevin phillips’ “american theocracy” has great insight into the role of religion in american culture and politics. if you haven’t read it, i recommend that you do.

    • Ian Reynolds says:

      Indeed, I really liked Phillips’ “American Theocracy” a wonderfully erudite polemic.

      There is something that might a huge difference to the prospects of US manufacturing and to US manufacturing employment. If we accept the need to reduce carbon emissions and factor this into the cost of shipping then the transportation of goods will become uneconomic, therefore it will be cheaper to produce locally removing the cheap labour equation from Chinese production, This may not effect laptops, iphones and ipads but it would in terms of larger, heavier domestic appliances, something to think about.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: